|
United States Involvement in the Holocaust
Directions: The following question requires you to construct
a coherent essay that shows your interpretations of Documents A through
G and your knowledge of the time period referred to in the question. High
scores will be earned only by essays that both cite key pieces of evidence
from the documents and draw on outside knowledge of the period.
1.
The United States government and its citizens did everything they
could to help the European Jewish population and to stop the atrocities
that occurred during the Holocaust in World War II.
Using the documents and your knowledge of this time period,
explain whether you agree or disagree with this statement.
Document A
Source: Joint Emergency Committee for European Jewish
Affairs; April 14, 1943
Document B
Source: John Pehle; U.S. Treasury Department, 1940-1944;
on establishing the War Refugee Board
|
We were advised by our friends in the State Department
that the State Department not only was not interested in the refugee
problem, but that they were actively suppressing information about
the extent of the Holocaust by sending instructions to their legation
in Switzerland not to permit private Jewish agencies to transmit
any such stories.
This suppression and cover up were the final straws in causing the
Secretary of Treasury Dept., Henry Morgenthau Jr. to go ahead with
the President on the establishment of the War Refugee Board.
|
Document C
Source: Excerpt from “Report to the Secretary on the Acquiescence
of this Government in the Murder of Jews”; January 13, 1944; prepared
by Treasury Department lawyer Josiah DuBois and signed by Randolph Paul.
|
The tragic history of this Government’s handling
of this matter reveals that certain State Department officials are
guilty of the following:
(1)
They have not only failed to use the Government machinery
at their disposal to rescue Jews from Hitler, but have even gone
so far as to use this Government machinery to prevent the rescue
of these Jews.
(2)
They have not only failed to cooperate with private organizations
in the efforts of these organizations to work out individual programs
of their own, but have taken steps designed to prevent these programs
from being put into effect.
(3)
They not only have failed to facilitate the obtaining of
information concerning Hitler’s plan to exterminate the Jews of
Europe but in their official capacity have gone so far as to surreptitiously
attempt to stop the obtaining of information concerning the murder
of the Jewish population of Europe.
(4)
They have tried to cover up the guilt by:
(a)
concealment and misrepresentation;
(b)
the giving of false and misleading explanations for their
failures to act and their attempts to prevent action; and
(c)
the issuance of false and misleading statements concerning
the “action” which they have taken to date.
|
Document
D
Source: Excerpt from a plan for rescue of refugees that
was submitted to the Bermuda Conference by Jewish leaders
|
AMERICAN JEWISH CONGRESS
330 WEST 42nd STREET NEW YORK CITY
STEPHEN S. WISE, President
CARL SHERMAN, Chairman, Executive Committee
NATHAN D. PERLMAN, Vice President
LEO H. LOWITZ, Vice President
LOUIS LIPSKY, Chairman, Governing Council
M. MALDWIN FERTIG, Chairman, Administrative Committee
JACOB LEICHTMAN, Treasurer
April 14, 1943
Hon. Sumner Wlles
Under Secretary of State
State Department
Washington, D.C.
My Dear Secretary Welles:
In behalf of the joint Emergency Committee for European Jewish Affairs,
comprising the American Jewish Committee the American Jewish Congress;
the B'nai B'rith the Jewish Labor Committee. the American Emergency
Committee for Zionist Affairs of the Zionist organization of America;
Hadassah; Mizrachi; and the Poale Zion; the Synagogue Council of
America; the Agudath Israel of America, Inc.; and the Union of Orthodox
Rabbis in America, we submit through you to the Bermuda Conference,
scheduled to open on April 19th, the enclosed Memorandum and appendix,
setting forth a program of rescue to be undertaken for the Jews
of Nazi-occupied Europe, otherwise doomed to destruction. The signatories,
to these Memoranda represent leading Jewish organizations in the
United States with whom are affiliated a large majority of the Jewish
population of this country.
These Memoranda set forth the principal projects representing, in
our considered judgment, basic action to be undertaken immediately
by the United Nations if the remnants of European Jewry are to be
saved from destruction…
|
Document E
Source: Excerpts from… Memo from Assistant Secretary of
State Breckinridge Long, to State Department Officials dated June 26,
1940, outlining effective ways to obstruct the granting of U.S. visas.
|
Immigrants
We can delay and effectively stop for a temporary period of indefinite
length the number of immigrants into the United States. We could
do this by simply advising our consuls, to put every obstacle in
the way and to require additional evidence and to resort to various
administrative devices which would postpone and postpone and postpone
the granting of the visas. However, this could only be temporary.
In order to make it more definite It would have to be done by suspension
of the rules under the law by the issuance of a proclamation of
emergency--which I take it we are not yet ready to proclaim.
Summing Up
We can effectively control non-immigrants by prohibiting the issuance
of visas
unless the consent of the Department to obtained in advance for
universal application.
We can temporarily prevent the number of immigrants from certain
localities such as Cuba, Mexico and other places of origin of German
intending immigrants by simply raising administrative obstacles.
|
Document F
Source: “This
is Nazi Brutality” by Ben Shahn; 1942; Printed by the
Government Printing Office for the Office of War Information
Note: Poster Reads:
“Radio Berlin. --It is officially announced: All men of
Lidice - Czechoslovakia - have been shot: The women deported to a concentration
camp: The Children sent to appropriate centers - The name of the village
was immediately abolished.
6/11/42/115P
Document G
Source: American Reverend Charles E. Coughlin's quotes
as reported in The Detroit News
|
"If Jews persist in supporting communism directly
or indirectly, that will be regrettable. By their failure to use
the press, the radio and the banking house, where they stand so
prominently, to fight communism as vigorously as they fight Naziism,
the Jews invite the charge of being supporters of communism."
-- November 28, 1938
"From European entanglements, from Naziism,
communism and their future wars, America must stand aloof. Keep
America safe for Americans and the Stars and Stripes the defender
of God."
-- January 2, 1939
"Must the entire world go to war for 600,000
Jews in Germany who are neither American, nor French, nor English
citizens, but citizens of Germany?"
-- January 30, 1939
|
|
|